December 5th, 2006 (03:20 am)
current behavior: thoughtful
current module: None
I was thinking about it on the way to school today, and came to the conclusion that Christmas gifts (and arguable and tradition with a exchange of gifts) is a waste of finances. Allow me to give a example to help explain.
Person A on Christmas gives Person B a gift that equals lets say $50 in value. Person B gives person A a gift of about the same value. In the end, each person is about even in value with the only person "making" money being the cooperation that the gifts were purchased from. Though it could be said that one of the two could have come out "ahead" in the gift exchange that seems to suggest and possibly promote a game of being stingy with gift giving in hopes that a person will come out ahead.
Now, I do also realize that gifts that are manufactured by one of the people can causes complications with my statement; that is until you start assigning monetary value to the resources, time, and effort of the manufactured gift. As a example, a person might decided to make a piece of jewelry for a friend, however the task of making jewelry is not instantaneous, and thus time is required as well as the resources to make the item. The crafter is still expending resources into the project, and so given that our market places loose rules on money = time/resources spent, a value can be assigned to homemade gifts.
The two exceptions I can see to this that breaks my conclusion is the situation of children. Due to their position in society and general lack of funds, they receive gifts essentially for free or at least a "reduced" expense of resources. This means that the parents and other people giving these children gifts are directly losing money with little or no return on their part. Given this outlook, no wonder children look forward to Christmas because they are literally getting free stuff.
The other situation in which my logic might break is in the rare situation of a person giving a gift to another with no expectation of anything in return. In other words; an act of kindness cannot occur without the existence of an ulterior motive. I find such a situation completely ridiculous to even consider, due to the belief that all actions are taken out of the desire to gain something. Of course this concept requires people to be open minded, and it seems that all most people have a lot of trouble even beginning to understand how this logic works, thus I shall explain more.
The reasoning behind this idea, is that unless their is a desire for a action, the action will not come to be. So any action that occurs has a reason behind it, and that reason is inevitably in some way selfish in nature.
*A boy might buy a girl a flower in hopes of having a relationship.
*A dog will act in a obedient manner in hopes of getting a treat.
*A person might join the military out of the financial advantage of working for the government.
This can be taken to a bit more of a extreme such as;
*A person might save another’s life knowing that by doing so they will have strong leverage over the saved person.
*A person giving blood so that you can say to others that they gave blood so other will look up to them.
More or less, you can take any situation and show that there could be a selfish motive behind it no matter how sincere the act might seem. And so it should be seen that the act of giving a gift is really just a meaningless act of giving to another out of tradition.
What I feel
I feel that if traditions are meaningless, they should not exist and be replaced with something that is more useful. In the situation of gift exchange on such occasions like Christmas, nobody is really gaining anything from the gifts accept for perhaps children. Why do the parents do these activities then? Perhaps to have leverage over their children, thus threats through out the year of "Behave or no presents" can come into existence. Need I argue my point anymore?
And so in conclusion, Christmas is a waste of money in which only the cooperations truly gain from the gift exchange activity. So when you all go shopping this holiday season, I hope you remember this (assuming you read it all) and realize you are bound by the chains of tradition.